7 II 2024: Israeli and Russian Irredentism

Irredentism is the passion, usually exploited by demagogues, to get back what is thought to be a nation’s former property. Russia presents itself as the successor state to the Russian Empires, and cites this as the basis for seizing territories from Ukraine, their pretense of respectability for this aggression being that they are simply taking back what once was the property of the Russian Empires. And, unless Russia’s grab for Ukraine is wholly frustrated, this same irredentism will probably be used to justify Russian invasion of Lithuania, Estonia, Latvia, Finland, and Poland.

Israel is doing the same thing on the West Bank and in Gaza, claiming a kind of “manifest destiny” for violence on the West Bank by “settlers” who have come to claim what God gave to their distant ancestors and for the police-action destruction of Gaza and deportation of millions of Palestinians.

I cannot see much difference between Israel and Russia. It is time to stop buying into Israel’s endless victimhood and affectation of democratic values and to begin being as tough with Israel as we would be with any other aggressor nation.